RSI and MACD: reading momentum
What the two most popular momentum indicators actually calculate, how people use them, and how they mislead.
Moving averages tell you direction. Momentum indicators try to tell you how strongly price is moving in that direction, and whether that strength is building or fading. RSI and MACD are the two you will see everywhere. Both are calculated entirely from past closing prices, which is the key to understanding both their uses and their limits.
RSI: the balance of gains and losses
The Relative Strength Index, introduced by J. Welles Wilder in 1978, compares the size of recent up-closes with the size of recent down-closes, usually over 14 periods, and scales the result from 0 to 100. A reading near 100 means nearly all recent movement was upward. A reading near 0 means nearly all of it was downward. A reading near 50 means gains and losses were roughly balanced.
The classic interpretation treats readings above 70 as overbought and below 30 as oversold, implying a reversal may be near. Many traders also use the 50 line as a simple momentum filter: above 50, recent strength favors the upside.
How RSI misleads
In a strong trend, RSI can stay above 70, or below 30, for weeks. Treating every reading above 70 as a reason to sell means selling into the strongest moves. Overbought describes what has happened, not what will. Divergences, where price makes a new high but RSI does not, are often cited as warnings, but they can persist for a long time before anything happens, and plenty never resolve the way the textbook suggests.
MACD: two averages compared
MACD, the Moving Average Convergence Divergence indicator developed by Gerald Appel, is built from exponential moving averages. With the standard 12, 26 and 9 settings:
- The MACD line is the 12-period EMA minus the 26-period EMA.
- The signal line is a 9-period EMA of the MACD line.
- The histogram is the MACD line minus the signal line.
When the MACD line is above zero, the shorter average is above the longer one, which is a trend reading similar to the EMA crossover from lesson 3. When the MACD line crosses above its signal line, short-term momentum is improving; crossing below, it is fading. A shrinking histogram shows momentum slowing even if price is still rising.
How MACD misleads
MACD is an average of averages, so it lags more than price itself. Its crossovers arrive late, and in sideways markets they whipsaw in exactly the way moving-average crossovers do. Its values are also in price units, so a MACD reading on bitcoin cannot be compared directly with one on a lower-priced coin.
Indicators are not independent evidence
This is the most important point in the lesson. EMA, RSI and MACD are all different arithmetic on the same closing prices. When all three agree, it can feel like three separate confirmations. It is closer to one observation described three ways. Adding more price-based indicators to a rule mostly adds parameters to tune, and every extra parameter makes overfitting easier. A simple rule built on one or two indicators you understand is usually more robust than a complicated one built on six.
The Algos demo shows RSI 14 and MACD 12/26/9 alongside the trend readout, with a plain-English line for each. Use it to practice reading them together, and to notice how often they simply restate the trend.
Key takeaways
- RSI compares recent gains with recent losses on a 0 to 100 scale.
- RSI can stay overbought or oversold for long periods in strong trends.
- MACD is the 12 EMA minus the 26 EMA, with a 9 EMA signal line.
- MACD lags and whipsaws in sideways markets.
- Price-based indicators largely restate each other; they are not independent confirmation.
In the Algos demo, read the RSI 14 and MACD readouts for BTC, ETH and SOL. For each symbol, write one sentence on what each indicator says and whether it agrees with the EMA trend readout, then note which readings told you something the trend did not.
Read RSI and MACD