Surplus course · lesson 6 of 7 · 9 min

Ethical outreach and avoiding scams

How to contact former owners honestly, and how owners can recognize the scams that target them.

People who are owed surplus have usually just been through something hard: a foreclosure, a tax sale, or the death of a relative. Outreach that is honest and respectful helps them. Outreach that is vague, pushy or misleading harms them, damages trust in the whole field, and may break the law. This lesson covers both sides: how to reach out well, and how owners can protect themselves.

Principles for outreach

Good outreach starts from a simple fact: the owner does not need you to get their money. They need information, and some will want help with paperwork. Your first message should give them enough to verify everything on their own, even if they never hire you. Owners who can check your claims independently are more likely to trust you, and the ones who decide to file on their own have made a reasonable choice that you should respect.

  • Say who you are and that you are a private business, not a government office.
  • Tell the owner they can claim the funds directly from the county or court at no cost.
  • Give the name of the office holding the funds so they can verify independently.
  • State your fee clearly and do not ask for any payment up front.
  • Give them time. No pressure, no false deadlines, no repeated calls after they say no.

Follow the rules for the contact method you use. Calls and texts are covered by federal telemarketing and consumer protection laws, including rules on automated dialing and texting without consent, and the National Do Not Call Registry. Mail is generally the safest first contact. Avoid language or designs that imitate official notices, such as seals, case-number styling or phrases like final notice, because that can be deceptive and may violate state law.

Be careful with information. You will often learn sensitive details: addresses, family relationships, debts. Use it only for the claim, store it securely, and do not share it with others. If you find that the owner has died, approach the family with care and do not assume who the heirs are.

Scams that target owners

Because surplus lists are public, scammers use them too. Common patterns include letters or calls that impersonate a county office and ask for a processing fee, offers to buy the right to the funds for a small fraction of the amount without explaining the real value, requests for bank login details or a Social Security number by phone, and people who file claims in an owner's name using stolen identity. A related crime, deed or title fraud, targets property records directly.

How owners can protect themselves

  1. Look up the county or court phone number yourself and call to confirm any surplus.
  2. Never pay a fee up front to receive money you are owed.
  3. Never give bank passwords or full identification numbers to someone who contacted you.
  4. Read any agreement fully, and ask for time to review it with someone you trust.
  5. Report suspected scams to your state attorney general and local police.

Scams often share the same signals: urgency, secrecy and money flowing the wrong way. A message that says the funds will be lost tomorrow, asks you not to contact the county, or asks you to pay before you are paid deserves suspicion. So does an offer to buy your claim for cash today without telling you how much the surplus is. A legitimate agent can tell you the amount, the office holding it and the deadline, and will wait while you check.

For professionals, one useful test is this: would you be comfortable if the owner showed your letter, your agreement and your fee to a judge or a reporter? If yes, you are probably on solid ground. If no, change your approach.

Surplus is designed around that principle. Its owner-facing features point people to the free, direct claim route first, and the professional feed is meant for people who intend to follow their state's rules.

Telemarketing, privacy and consumer protection laws apply to outreach and vary by state. This is not legal advice. Have an attorney review your outreach materials and agreements before you use them.

Key takeaways

  • Identify yourself as private, disclose the free direct option and state your fee clearly.
  • Follow federal and state rules for calls, texts and mail, and never imitate an official notice.
  • Scammers impersonate counties, charge upfront fees and steal identities.
  • Owners should verify any surplus by calling the county or court on a number they look up themselves.
Do it now · the tool comes with the course

Choose one fictional listing in the Surplus demo and draft a short first-contact letter to its former owner that meets every principle in this lesson. Then reread it as the owner and remove anything that could feel like pressure or look official.

Pick a sample listing