Surplus course · lesson 2 of 7 · 9 min

Tyler v. Hennepin County and why it matters

The 2023 Supreme Court decision that said governments cannot keep a home's surplus value after a tax sale.

For many years, a number of states allowed a county that took a property for unpaid taxes to keep the entire value, even when the property was worth far more than the debt. Critics called this home equity theft. In 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court addressed the practice directly in Tyler v. Hennepin County.

The case

Geraldine Tyler owned a condominium in Minneapolis, in Hennepin County, Minnesota. After she moved into a senior community, the property taxes went unpaid. With interest and penalties, the debt grew to about 15,000 dollars. Under Minnesota law at the time, the county took title to the condo and sold it for 40,000 dollars. It kept the full amount, including roughly 25,000 dollars more than she owed.

Tyler sued, arguing that keeping the surplus was a taking of her property without just compensation, which the Fifth Amendment prohibits. In May 2023 the Supreme Court agreed unanimously. Writing for the Court, Chief Justice John Roberts concluded that a government may take property to satisfy a tax debt, but it may not use the debt as an excuse to take more property than it is owed. The surplus value belonged to the owner.

What changed after the decision

The ruling applies nationwide, but it did not write a single procedure for every state. Legislatures in states whose laws allowed governments to keep surplus value have been revising their tax foreclosure statutes since 2023, and the new rules differ. Some created claim processes for former owners, some changed notice requirements, and some changed how tax sales are conducted. Questions about how the ruling applies to older sales, how surplus is measured, and how claims must be filed have been the subject of further legislation and litigation in several states.

For your purposes, three practical points follow. First, in tax sales, there may now be surplus funds available in states where, a few years ago, there would have been none. Second, the claim rules in those states may be new, so information you find online may be outdated. Third, when you read any summary of a state's surplus law, check the date and confirm it against the current statute.

What it does not cover

Tyler concerned a government keeping surplus from a tax sale. Mortgage foreclosures by private lenders were already generally subject to rules requiring that surplus be paid to junior lienholders and then the former owner, under each state's foreclosure law. The decision also does not change the priority of other creditors. A second mortgage holder or a judgment creditor with a lien on the property may still be paid from the surplus before the owner.

  • Decided by the U.S. Supreme Court in 2023, unanimously.
  • Holding: a government cannot keep surplus value beyond the tax debt; doing so is a taking under the Fifth Amendment.
  • Effect: states that allowed it have been changing their laws, with different procedures.
  • Always confirm the current version of your state's statute.

Surplus organizes listings by sale type, so you can tell tax sale surplus from sheriff, trustee and mortgage foreclosure surplus at a glance. That matters because the claim process and the office holding the money often differ by sale type.

This is a summary for education, not legal advice. If you think you lost surplus value in a tax sale, especially an older one, consult a licensed attorney in your state about your rights and deadlines.

Key takeaways

  • In Tyler v. Hennepin County (2023), the Supreme Court held that keeping a tax sale surplus beyond the debt is an unconstitutional taking.
  • States have been revising their tax sale laws since, with different claim procedures.
  • Information about surplus rules in a given state may be outdated; check the current statute.
  • Other lienholders may still be paid before the former owner.
Do it now · the tool comes with the course

In the Surplus demo, separate the sample listings into tax sales and other foreclosure sales. For one state in the tax sale group, find the current statute or county page on surplus claims and note whether it mentions changes made after 2023.

Sort listings in Surplus