How real estate commissions work, and what changed in 2024
Who pays whom in a home sale, why commissions were always negotiable, and what the NAR settlement changed for buyers and sellers.
For decades, most American home sales followed the same pattern. The seller signed a listing agreement with a brokerage that set a commission, often quoted as a percentage of the sale price. The listing brokerage then offered part of that commission to whichever brokerage brought the buyer. The buyer usually paid no agent directly, but the cost was built into the deal, and the seller paid it out of the sale proceeds at closing.
On a $500,000 home, a 6 percent commission is $30,000. That is real money from the seller's equity, and it is why more people now ask what they are actually paying for.
Commissions were always negotiable
No law sets real estate commissions. A percentage that looks standard is a business custom, not a rule. Sellers and buyers have always been able to negotiate the rate, pay a flat fee, or pay only for specific services. What changed in 2024 is how openly that negotiation happens.
The 2024 NAR settlement
In 2024 the National Association of Realtors settled lawsuits by home sellers who argued that the old system kept commissions high. The resulting practice changes took effect on August 17, 2024. Two matter most for consumers.
- Offers of compensation to buyer's agents can no longer be published in the MLS, the shared database of listings agents use.
- Buyers working with an agent who is an NAR member or MLS participant must sign a written agreement before touring a home. The agreement must state the agent's compensation as a specific amount or rate, and the agent cannot receive more than that amount.
Sellers can still choose to pay part of a buyer's costs, including a buyer's agent fee, as a negotiated term of the deal. Buyers can ask for that in their offer. But nobody is required to, and the amount is now visible and negotiated rather than assumed.
Read any buyer or listing agreement before you sign it. Check what services are included, how compensation is calculated, how long the agreement lasts and how you can end it. These agreements are contracts, and in Iowa licensees must disclose whom they represent. If one brokerage works with both the buyer and the seller, ask in writing how that is handled and what each side can expect.
Alternatives to a percentage commission
You can sell a home yourself with no brokerage at all, often called for sale by owner. You can hire a full-service agent at a negotiated rate. Or you can pay for specific services: listing, offer management, inspection coordination, title work and closing, each at a set price. The trade-off is how much of the work you want to do yourself and how much professional help you want behind it.
The Housing Market uses that third model in Iowa. Sellers pay flat, à la carte fees for the services they choose, capped at $10,000 in total, and nothing is due until closing. Buyers pay no commission. A licensed Iowa broker reviews listing agreements and disclosures and handles closings. Prices are published on its site, may change, and the price shown when you choose a service is the price you pay.
Whatever route you choose, compare the total cost in dollars for your price range, not percentages in the abstract, and compare the services you actually get for it.
Key takeaways
- No law sets commission rates; they have always been negotiable.
- Since August 17, 2024, buyer's agent compensation is no longer offered through the MLS.
- Buyers working with an NAR member or MLS participant sign a written agreement stating compensation before touring.
- Compare total dollar cost and services, not percentages.
- Flat, à la carte pricing lets you pay only for the services you use.
Open The Housing Market's pricing page, drag the slider to your home's likely sale price, and compare a 6 percent commission with the flat-fee total. Write down the difference in dollars.
Compare the math