The Housing Market course · lesson 2 of 7 · 9 min

Pricing a home

How to read comparable sales, why the asking price is a strategy, and how appraisals keep everyone honest.

A home is worth what a ready, willing and able buyer will pay for it in the current market. Your job when pricing is to estimate that number from evidence, not from what you paid, what you owe, or what you need to buy next.

Comparable sales

The best evidence is recent sales of similar homes nearby, called comparables or comps. Good comps share the same neighborhood or school area, sold recently, and are close in size, age, bedrooms, bathrooms, lot and condition. Sold prices matter most. Pending sales tell you where the market is heading. Active listings are your competition, not proof of value, because sellers can ask anything.

  1. Find three to six homes that sold recently within a short distance of yours.
  2. Note size, beds, baths, garage, basement finish, lot and condition.
  3. Adjust for differences: a comp with a finished basement your home lacks sold for more than yours would.
  4. Look at the range of adjusted prices, then where your home falls within it.
  5. Check current active and pending listings to see what buyers will compare you to.

Price per square foot is a quick check, not an answer. A small home and a large home on the same street rarely sell at the same price per foot. The county assessor's value is set for property tax purposes and often differs from market value, so do not rely on it alone.

Price is a strategy

Buyers search in price bands, such as up to $250,000 or up to $350,000. A home priced just over a common threshold may be missed by buyers searching just under it. Overpricing usually costs more than it gains: the home sits, buyers wonder what is wrong with it, and the eventual price can end up lower than a realistic list price would have produced. Pricing at the evidence tends to bring the most buyers in the first weeks, when interest is highest.

Condition matters as much as location. Two identical floor plans can sell far apart if one has a new roof and updated systems and the other needs work. Be honest about your home's condition, because buyers and their inspectors will be.

The appraisal

If your buyer is borrowing, their lender will order an appraisal: an independent estimate of value by a licensed appraiser. If it comes in below the contract price, the lender will lend based on the lower value, and the buyer and seller usually renegotiate, the buyer adds cash, or the deal ends under the contract's terms. A price grounded in comps is the best protection against a low appraisal.

Getting a professional opinion

A licensed broker's opinion of value is a useful check on your own work, especially if your home is unusual or the market is shifting. The Housing Market offers a free Home Price Evaluation: you answer a few questions and a local licensed broker sends a street-by-street evaluation, with no obligation to list.

If your own comps and a professional opinion land in a similar range, you can price with confidence. If they disagree, find out why before you choose a number. The gap usually points to a comp that was not truly comparable, or a feature one of you weighed differently.

An evaluation or comparative market analysis is not an appraisal, and no estimate guarantees a sale price. Markets change, sometimes quickly.

Key takeaways

  • Price from recent sold comps nearby, adjusted for differences.
  • Active listings are competition, not proof of value; assessed value is not market value.
  • Price with search bands in mind; overpricing often ends in a lower sale.
  • A financed buyer's appraisal checks the price, so ground it in evidence.
  • Compare your own analysis with a licensed broker's opinion.
Do it now · the tool comes with the course

Request The Housing Market's free Home Price Evaluation for your home (or a home you are watching), then compare the broker's number with three comps you find yourself and note any gap.

Get a free home evaluation